Hair Accessories · 4 min read

Are Satin Scrunchies Good for Your Hair?

By Vika Fashions ·

Vika Fashions satin scrunchies and tulip hair scrunchies, pictured for a guide on whether satin scrunchies are good for your hair
In this guide
  1. What satin actually is
  2. What dermatologists say about hair ties
  3. What a scrunchie can and cannot do
  4. How to wear a satin scrunchie
  5. When a clip is the better choice
  6. Questions people ask
  7. Sources

Satin scrunchies are a gentle way to tie hair, for two plain reasons: the fabric is smooth, and the band is wide and soft, so it holds hair loosely instead of squeezing it. That fits what dermatologists recommend for ponytails. What a scrunchie cannot do is fix damage or stop hair fall, and it is worth being clear about both.

What satin actually is

Satin is not a fibre. It is a way of weaving. The Encyclopaedia Britannica defines satin as any fabric constructed by the satin weave method, characterised by a smooth surface and usually a lustrous face. It was originally made of silk and is now made of other fibres too.

So when you compare "satin" and "silk", you are comparing two different kinds of thing. Silk is a fibre. Satin is a weave that can be made from silk, polyester or other yarns. Many satin scrunchies at everyday prices are made from polyester satin, and that is fine: the smooth surface comes from the weave.

Satin scrunchieSilk scrunchieThin elastic band
What it isSmooth woven fabric over elasticSilk fabric over elasticBare or thinly covered elastic
SurfaceSmoothSmoothGrippy
Width on the hairWide and softWide and softNarrow
CostLowHighLowest
CareEasy to hand washNeeds gentle careNone

What dermatologists say about hair ties

The American Academy of Dermatology's advice for hair that is pulled back is to wear it loosely and use covered rubber bands made especially for styling hair. A scrunchie is exactly that: an elastic with a fabric cover.

An older statement from the same academy goes further. In a 2004 release, dermatologist Dr Draelos recommended fabric scrunchies, which loosely hold the hair together, and said rubber bands should never be used for ponytails.

Notice what the advice is about. It is the loose hold and the covered elastic that matter. We have not found a dermatology source that says satin in particular is better than other soft fabrics, so we will not claim it. What we can say is that a smooth, wide, loosely worn scrunchie matches the advice well.

Comparison of a satin scrunchie and a thin elastic band: the scrunchie has a wide soft band, a smooth surface and a loose hold, while the thin elastic is narrow, grips tightly and can snag when pulled off
The difference is in the width and the grip.

What a scrunchie can and cannot do

Honest expectations

  • It can hold a ponytail or bun without a tight ring around the hair.
  • It can come off without dragging, because the fabric slides.
  • It cannot repair split ends, make hair grow or treat hair fall.
  • It cannot make a tight hairstyle safe. A tight ponytail pulls, whatever is holding it.

If you are losing more hair than usual, a hair tie is not the answer. The AAD notes that hair loss has many causes, and a dermatologist can tell you which applies to you.

How to wear a satin scrunchie

  1. Wrap it fewer times than you would an elastic. Two loops are usually enough. If you need three or four for it to hold, the ponytail is too heavy for that scrunchie.
  2. Keep ponytails low or mid-height for everyday wear. High, tight ponytails pull most at the hairline.
  3. Use one at night. A loose, low ponytail or a loose braid tied with a scrunchie keeps long hair from tangling while you sleep.
  4. Slide it off, do not pull. Loosen the loops first.
  5. Wash it. A scrunchie picks up hair oil and product. Hand wash in mild soap and dry flat.

When a clip is the better choice

Silky satin can slide on very smooth or very heavy hair. If your scrunchie keeps slipping, a clip may suit the job better. A claw clip holds a twist with no elastic at all, and a banana clip carries a heavy ponytail along its length. See our claw clip hairstyles, how to use a banana clip, and whether claw clips are bad for hair.

Shop all hairbands and scrunchies.

Questions people ask

Are satin scrunchies good for hair?

They are a gentle choice. The smooth fabric and wide band hold hair loosely, which is what dermatologists advise for ponytails. They do not treat damage or hair fall.

Are satin or silk scrunchies better?

Both have a smooth surface. Silk is a natural fibre and costs more. Satin is a weave, usually made from polyester at everyday prices, and is easier to wash. For holding a ponytail loosely, either works.

Can I sleep with a satin scrunchie in my hair?

Yes, if it is loose. A low, loose ponytail or braid is the comfortable way to do it.

Why does my satin scrunchie keep slipping?

Smooth fabric grips less than bare elastic, which is the point. On very silky or heavy hair, add one more loop, tie the ponytail lower, or use a clip instead.

Sources

More from the Journal